Skip to main content

Pasture-Raised vs Free Range Eggs: What's the Difference?



#thebarefootmom


   My family consumes a lot of eggs, about 3 dozen a week between the 4 of us. Clean eating is really important to us, so I care a lot about the quality of eggs we're getting. I'm planning to get a small backyard children coop built this spring so we can raise a few hens ourselves, but until then, we're stuck getting most of our eggs from the supermarket (I do buy eggs from our neighbor when he has extra). There are so many different terms on egg cartons though, it can be a bit tricky to figure out which eggs are best. I've spent some time researching and here's what I found out:

 

Caged hens

(which produce pretty much any eggs that don't state they're free range, pasture raised, cage free, certified humane, or organic) are kept in tiny cages, some as small as 67 square inches! Most never see the light of day. Most are fed a soy or corn (probably GMO) diet.

 

Cage-Free hens

are given slightly more space since they are not confined to cages but most still never see the light of day. They spend they're entire egg laying lives confined to a crowded barn being fed corn or soy.

 

Free-Range

is an especially misleading term when it comes to hens. Free Range hens are not required to have more than 2 square foot a piece and while they must have access to the outdoors, many never actually see it. Many are kept in crowded barns with only a single access point or two to a small caged in outdoor space. They are typically fed a corn or soy based diet. Free-range  unfortunately does not mean hens who are free to roam and forage outdoors like one might think.

 

Pasture-Raised

are the eggs you want to look for. While, as far as I can find, there are no current regulations,  this is the term being used by sustainable farmers to refer to hens that are given ample time and space (at least 108 square foot per bird) outside to forge for bugs like chickens are supposed to (they are fed some feed too).  If you really want to be sure your getting quality eggs from healthy humanely raised hens, look for pasture-raised eggs with the "Certified Humane"  seal. The seal means the eggs come from farms that have been inspected to meet very specific standards including the freedom to roam freely during the daytime.


   According to a study out of Pennsylvania State University, pasture-raised hens produce eggs that contain several times the amount of both vitamin D and E than conventionally farmed eggs. And twice the amount of omega 3 fatty acids. Healthy chickens produce healthy eggs.


   Another term I've seen on egg cartons lately that drives me crazy is "Vegetarian Fed". Guys, this isn't a good thing. Chickens are omnivores, they're supposed to eat insects, worms, and grass. So please don't be fooled by this sales ploy.


   All in all, healthier happier chickens who are free to roam and forage for insects and worms produce healthier eggs. Look for the term "Pasture-Raised" and the "Certified Humane" seal when shopping for eggs.

For more information visit:

https://certifiedhumane.org

https://www.fsis.usda.gov/wps/portal/fsis/topics/food-safety-education/get-answers/food-safety-fact-sheets/food-labeling/meat-and-poultry-labeling-terms/meat-and-poultry-labeling-terms



Follow me on:
Facebook
Pinterest
Instagram

Comments

  1. I haven't seen "vegetarian fed" on eggs. It makes it seem as if they were fed by a human who eats a vegetarian diet! I totally agree with you, though. Chickens are omnivores and will eat insects if they have access to them. This is healthy for them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lol @ chickens fed by vegetarians! Definitely going to be the picture I imagine in my head now :-)
      I've noticed a big difference in the quality of eggs from chickens fed strickly grains and those that are free to eat insects and such. The yolks are a much brighter color and they taste better too!

      Delete
  2. Love this!!! My family and I are on a real tight budget so we cut back on eggs since pasture-raised are expensive. But I really want to have chickens once we have some land, so I'm with you there! And funny thing about reading this today is that I just talked to my husband (who is from a farming family) about corn-fed beef is full of saturated fats when they should be eating grass to make omega-3 fats (anti-inflammatory fats), which is what inspired my post on 'The Price of Convenience' this week. He told me that few farmers are having to produce for a very high demand, so they are doing the best they can with the information they have. I think it's the same for chickens. Chicken is in high demand, so to match the convenience of consumers, farmers are having to cage them and feed them corn/soy because there isn't enough grass for all of them to eat. As a result, their meat and eggs are full of saturated fats instead of anti-inflammatory omega 3 fats. The price of the convenience of buying chicken and eggs from a grocery store at any time....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that high demand probably plays a big role. Maybe the answer is more backyard chicken coops :-)
      Can't wait to get started with our chicken coop this spring! Quality eggs can definitely get pricey, it will be nice to be producing some of our own.

      Delete
  3. Thank you for all this great info! It's so hard figuring out what everything is once you're in the grocery store especially if you have a family in tow. I watched a CBC Marketplace special about this not too long ago. Decisions, decisions, decisions!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Your welcome! So many confusing terms out there!

      Delete
  4. Thank you for clarifying that. it's good to know.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you for helping everyone understand I only buy organic eggs

    ReplyDelete
  6. Our girls are pastured raised. They love their free living lifestyle and we love the eggs they give us.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We finally got our first batch of chicks a couple months ago. So excited to start getting eggs from my own hens :-)

      Delete
  7. I've always been confused by the difference in eggs. Which are actually the best for your health? This post was incredibly helpful. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Marketing terms can definitely be confusing.
      Thanks for reading :-)

      Delete
  8. It's so sad that "free range" can be so little. How is 2 sq ft free range?! Thank you for explaining this to me so I can make the right decisions on my eggs from now on.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Really useful article, with lots of information I could use. I love eggs!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great information! I live in Germany and farm/pasture eggs are very easy to get and affordable, because they have way more regulations on such things. It’s crazy how much better those eggs taste than the ones I’ve had in America from the grocery store.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's great that they are so easy to get in Germany! Wish the US would implement better regulations. It is amazing how much better eggs from happy healthy hens taste!

      Delete
  11. Yes! I look for pasture-raised, too. This is a GREAT breakdown. So helpful!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Learning To Read Is Not A Race

So much emphasis is put on early literacy these days. Many school districts expect children to be reading by the end (or sometimes even the beginning) of kindergarten. While there is certainly nothing wrong with a child learning to read early, not all kids are developmentally ready to read at age 5, and that's okay. In this post I share several reasons why learning to read isn't a race.







Developmental Readiness
Kids all develop at their own pace. We know this when it comes to learning to walk or climbing the jungle gym or being ready for slumber parties but is often over looked when it comes to learning to read. Not all kids are developmentally there at the same age.  

Pushing kids to read before they're ready can cause a lot of frustration and resentment. It can destroy a child's chance to develop a love for reading by turning it into a frustrating chore. 


Reading Isn't The Only Way To Learn New Information
One of the reasons reading is pushed so early is to get kids re…

Make A Simple Compost Bin (a fun way to teach kids about soil)

We did a fun unit on soil last year and our big culminating project was setting up our own backyard compost bin. It ended up being much more simple to do than I originally thought it would be. In fact it's so simple, everyone should consider starting one! It's a great way to reduce your household waste, teach kids about soil and composting, and you end up with some excellent soil for your garden out of the process.




Setting Up A Compost Bin:
The first thing you need to do is pick a place for your bin. The best location will get a few hours of sun a day (the heat will help speed up the composting process) but not too much sun because you want your compost to stay moist. You also want to pick a spot somewhat close to the house so adding kitchen scraps is easy. 
Once you've chosen a location, it's time to actually set up your bin. Your compost bin can be as simple as just a pile in your yard (I personally don't use this method because we have too many critters around here…

5 Reasons To Let Your Kids Go Barefoot

I'm always surprised by how many concerned comments we get from well meaning strangers when my kids are barefoot in public. Comments like "Be careful, there are sharp rocks out here" or "Ouch, don't the wood chips hurt their feet?" I know these people mean well and are genuinely concerned but their concern is misplaced. Going barefoot has many benefits and wearing shoes too often can actually be damaging.


In this post I will share 5 ways going barefoot is beneficial for children (and adults too).




Proper Foot And Leg Development:
Wearing shoes affects the way a person steps. It requires using different sets of muscles differently than walking barefoot. Over time this can affect the development of the foot and leg muscles.
Modern shoes are constricting. Over time they can actually change the shape of a person's feet. Shoes can squish the bones of the feet together, affecting toe spread and arch. 
Flat feet are rare in places where shoes are seldom worn. Toe sp…

Learning About The Human Body Part 1: The Skeletal And Muscular Systems

At the end of each school year, I sit down with my daughter to discuss what topics she most wants to learn about the next year. One of her science topics she picked to study this year was the human body. Instead of ordering a boxed curriculum set, I decided to put together my own human body unit. In this 3 part series I will share some of the activities and resources we used for each of the body systems starting with the skeletal and muscular systems.






The Human Skeletal System


Our skeletons are the frame of our body. They give us structure, without them our bodies would be limp like noodles. They also provide places for muscles to attach so our bodies can move.


Why Does Your Body Need Calcium? Experiment:

This is a simple experiment you can do to explore why calcium is important for our bones.

You will need:

-several clean chicken bones

-vinegar 

-a bowl with a lid or plastic wrap to cover it

Let your child examine a clean chicken bone. Note how hard it is.

Place several clean chicken bones int…

Six Fun Activities for Teaching Sight Word Recognition and Spelling

Sight words are words that you recognize by sight instead of sounding them out phonetically. Most of us do the vast majority of our reading by sight. When your reading a book you aren't sounding out words as you go, your reading by sight. You recognize the words because you've seen them many times before. The Dolche List is a list of the 315 most commonly used words in the English language. About 80% of the words in children's literature and 50% of the words in adult literature are compromised of these 315 words. Once a child has mastered these words, reading becomes much easier. In this post I'll share some of my favorite fun hands on sight word games and activities.


Flash card games:    We have several flash card games we like to play. Some of our favorites are Sight Word Go Fish and Sight Word memory. Making sight word flash cards is simple. I just write the sight words we're working on on 3 x 5 cards or even just rectangle pieces of construction paper. I don'…