Skip to main content

What Natural Cleaners Kill Germs Best? A Homeschool Science Experiment

Check out the results of our homeschool science experiment testing the cleaning power of various natural cleaning products!
   
When I get ready to order curriculum and supplies before the start of each school year, I like to sit down with my daughter and ask what she would like to learn about that year. I like her input, children tend to be much more eager about learning when it's something that interests them. 

This year she asked to learn about germs so we ordered  a kit called The World of Germs from The Young Scientist's Club's Magic School Bus series (you can check them out here). The last several projects in the kit involved growing bacteria on agar in petri dishes. She had so much fun, she wanted to do more, so we ordered some prefilled agar petri dishes from Amazon (you can order your own here) and decided to design a few of our own experiments. The first thing she wanted to try was testing which of our household cleaners killed germs best and so we set out to design a simple experiment to figure it out.

Our Experiment: Which Natural Cleaners Kill Germs Best?

First we gathered up our usual household cleaners; white vinegar, hydrogen peroxide, homemade essential oil spray ( eucalyptus, rosemary, clove, and lemongrass essential oils in distilled water), and castile soap and water.  

Then I had her write a hypothesis and we set up our experiment.  The petri dishes I ordered come pre filled with agar (bacteria growing medium) so there's no preparation, they come ready to use. We taped off two equally dirty sections of my kitchen counter and labeled them A and B.


Then we split a petri dish in half by drawing a line down the center with a permanent marker and labeled the sides A and B. 

Using a sterile cotton swab (that came with the petri dishes we ordered) we swabbed area A on the counter and gently smeared it all over side A on the petri dish. Then we cleaned area B on the counter with white vinegar and let it dry. Using a fresh sterile swab, we then swabbed area B and smeared it on side B of the petri dish. We replaced the petri dish lid and then  it was time to let our bacteria grow. 

We created our own incubator by putting warm water bottles in a large pot with a lid. We set the petri dish inside and put it in a dark cupboard for a few days, replacing the warm water bottles every few hours to keep the bacteria warm. After about 3 days these were our results:


Side A (our control) grew lots of bacteria. Side B, the side cleaned by vinegar grew only a few colonies. Vinegar appears to be a fairly effective cleaner!

I had her record the results both by drawing a picture and counting and recording numbers of colonies. Then we repeated the experiment 3 times for our other 3 cleaners.




Results from our "what natural cleaners work best experiment"

Our Results

They all appeared to kill most bacteria. Hydrogen peroxide worked the best. Not a single bacterial colony grew on its side of the petri dish! 

The essential oil spray was our least effective cleaner, which inspired our next experiment, Do Essential Oils Really Kill Germs and Which Ones Kill Germs Best?



Follow me on:

Facebook
Pinterest
Instagram

Comments

  1. What a fun kit and experiment! My kids would love this!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It was definitely a fun experiment, my daughter really enjoyed it :-)

      Delete
  2. What a fun experiment. Good to know that about E.O. I hope your kids had a fun time and learned something.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great that you ask your daughter what she would like to study... good idea! Interesting results - thanks for that information. :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. I posted your post to my Facebook page :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Oooh, interesting! Oils are so popular as cleaners these days, too!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for reading! I was a little surprised that oils appeared to perform the worst.

      Delete
  6. What a cool idea! I know inspiring people to test bacteria probably wasn’t the main point of this post but now I want to do it with my boys!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You should do it! It was such a fun way to learn about bacteria!

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Water Relay Races For Kids

I don't know about your kids, but mine absolutely love games involving water and getting wet in the summer time. In  this post I share 5 of our favorite water relay races to play with friends. These are perfect for birthday parties, homeschool get togethers, and other group events. Sponge Relay: For this relay you will need: - 2 teams of several kids each -2 large sponges -4 small buckets or containers of some sort Divide your participants into 2 teams and have each team line up single file at a predetermined starting place.  Hand out a sponge to the first participant in each line. Set a bucket of water by each team. Set an empty bucket about 20 ft away from each team.  The two empty buckets should be the same size and should have a "fill line" marked half way up. On a count of 3 (or ready set go) the first participant in each line should dip their sponge in the bucket of water, run to the empty bucket, squeeze the water from their spo

Make Your Own Mineral Identification Kit

One of my family's favorite hobbies is rock hounding. We love collecting and trying to identify neat rock and mineral specimens that we come across. You can put together your own simple kit for identifying rocks and minerals with materials you likely already have around your home. In this post I will explain how to put together your own mineral identification kit and how to use it to identify rocks and minerals you find on your adventures. Making a Rock and Mineral ID Kit Grab yourself a printable Rock and Mineral Journal for recording your observations here:  Printable Rock and Mineral Journal ,  and then gather the following supplies: -A pencil -A coin -An iron nail -A piece of glass (an old pocket mirror works well) -A ceramic tile -A small watertight bottle or container -Some vinegar -A magnet  -A magnifying glass -A dropper (optional)  -Rock and mineral guide (optional)  -A small container or bag to keep it all in Fill the small watertight

STEM Art: 21 STEAM Project Ideas

My kids love STEM projects and we're always looking for ways to add more art to our homeschool days, so I decided I am going to try to dedicate one morning a week this year to STEM art activities. In this post I share some of the ideas we're planning to try, plus a few favorites we've done in the past. What is STEM Education? STEM education is a blended and often hands on approach to teaching science, technology, engineering, and mathematics, which are some of today's fastest growing industries. STEM education offers students the opportunity to problem solve and work on real world problems and questions. Sometimes the acronym STEAM is used, to include the arts. Adding art to STEM education encourages creative thinking and problem solving skills. It can also help make the other included subjects more appealing to some students. STEM Art Projects  Penny Spinners-   Learn about centrifugal force and make your own spinning tops with this fun post from Teach Beside Me. Explo

40 Things To Look At Under A Microscope

Microscopes are a scientific instrument that all kids should get a chance to learn how to use. There are so many everyday things that look really amazing up-close. Under a microscope you can see that objects and even plants and animals are made of tiny intricate parts. The microscopic world is amazing! In this post I share 40 things to try looking at up-close under a microscope. 40 Things To Look At Under A Microscope: 1. A feather  2. Soil 3. An insect wing 4. A human hair 5. An animal hair 6. Pond water 7. Diatomacious earth-  diatomacious earth looks SO cool magnified! 8. Cheek swab 9. An insect leg 10. A drop of blood 11. Mold 12. Sand 13. A shaving from a chicken bone- try both a piece of hard bone from the outside and some spongy bone from inside a bone. 14. Kombucha 15. Snake or lizard skin after they shed  16. A flower petal 17. A sliver of wood 18. Sugar 19. Salt- try different types 20. Thread 21. Saliva 22. A s

Learning About The Human Body Part 1: The Skeletal And Muscular Systems

At the end of each school year, I sit down with my daughter to discuss what topics she wants to learn about the next year. One of her science topics she picked to study this year was the human body. Instead of ordering a boxed curriculum set, I decided to put together my own human body unit. In this post I share some of the resources we used for learning about the human skeletal and muscular systems, plus instructions for a couple hands on learning activities. You can find my post about the human respiratory and circulatory systems  here , and my post about the human digestive and nervous systems  here . The Human Skeletal System Our skeletons are the frame of our body. They give us structure, without them our bodies would be limp like noodles. They also provide places for muscles to attach so our bodies can move. Why Does Your Body Need Calcium? Experiment: This is a simple experiment you can do to explore why calcium is important for our bones. You will need: -several clean